When Executive Order 14173 was issued, it sent shockwaves through the federal contracting community. By revoking EO 11246, which had governed federal contracting for over six decades, this new order introduced uncertainty and left many contractors scrambling to understand the new compliance landscape.
With no clear guidance on how to ensure non-discriminatory employment practices, many businesses have adopted a “wait and see” approach—unsure of how to proceed in the absence of a structured compliance framework.
Key Differences Between EO 11246 and EO 14173
Both EO 11246 and EO 14173 prohibit discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. However, their approach to enforcement is vastly different:
- EO 11246: Required affirmative action plans and mandated statistical analysis to help contractors assess hiring, promotion, and termination practices. This structured process ensured fair and legally sound employment decisions.
- EO 14173: Eliminates affirmative action mandates and does not outline a specific compliance framework for federal contractors. Without clear standards, businesses are left questioning how to demonstrate compliance and prevent discrimination.
What This Means for Federal Contractors
The lack of clear enforcement mechanisms has raised concerns about how contractors will be held accountable under the new order. Key questions remain:
- How will compliance be measured without affirmative action plans?
- What enforcement actions, if any, will federal agencies take?
- How can businesses ensure fair hiring practices without defined standards?
The Role of Statistical Analysis: A Misconception
One of the most misunderstood aspects of EO 11246 was its use of statistical analysis. Many believed it promoted preferential hiring based on race, sex, or other protected characteristics. However, this was never its intent.
Instead, these analytical tools were designed to:
- Identify potential disparities in hiring and promotions
- Ensure that employment decisions were merit-based and aligned with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
- Provide a structured way to assess fairness in the workplace
Without these safeguards, there is concern that unintentional bias in hiring and employment practices may go unnoticed.
What’s Next? Expected Compliance Guidelines
While uncertainty remains, some clarity is expected soon. The Department of Justice is set to release compliance guidelines by May 21, 2025. These guidelines may provide:
- New standards for evaluating discrimination claims
- Guidance on reporting and enforcement procedures
- Clarification on contractor obligations moving forward
Until then, many federal contractors remain in limbo, waiting for further direction.
How Contractors Can Navigate the Transition
While the long-term impact of EO 14173 remains unclear, federal contractors should take proactive steps to maintain compliance and protect their organizations:
- Continue to Promote Fair Hiring Practices – Even without affirmative action mandates, maintaining inclusive and merit-based hiring can help avoid legal and reputational risks.
- Stay Informed – Monitor updates from the Department of Justice, OFCCP, and other regulatory bodies for further guidance.
- Assess Internal Policies – Conduct internal reviews to ensure that hiring, promotion, and compensation practices remain transparent and equitable.
- Prepare for Future Compliance Updates – The regulatory landscape is evolving, and new compliance requirements could emerge following legal challenges or policy revisions.
Final Thoughts
The revocation of EO 11246 and the implementation of EO 14173 represent a major shift in federal contractor requirements. While some view the removal of affirmative action mandates as a step toward a neutral playing field, others argue that it leaves too much room for ambiguity.
As federal contractors await further guidance, the best approach is to stay informed, uphold fair employment practices, and prepare for potential regulatory changes.
Need guidance on federal contractor compliance? Contact us today for expert insights and support.